Penal Code may be related to civil lawsuit between individuals. In this article, not only does Minnesota lawyer not only lead to a client's lawsuit, but also what what a lawyer can do to prevent a criminal action against a client that may cause a criminal proceeding I am focusing. First, a civil lawyer contacted an experienced Minnesota criminal lawyer to evaluate the possibility of criminal proceedings and to support the formulation of an effective settlement strategy to repel the prosecution, a criminal proceeding It is essential to try to avoid; the ability to pursue criminal charges.
In contrast to universal beliefs, neither ABA model rules nor Minnesota's professional ethics rules prohibit the use of the "criminal detention" clause in settlement agreements. Nonetheless, lawyers need to carefully consider the expert ethics rules and the relevant laws of the law.
In 1992, the American Bar Association Standing Committee on Occupational Ethics published a formal opinion analyzing the question of whether plaintiffs posed a threat posed in civil lawsuits. The ABA Committee revealed by law of professional ethics that lawyers are not prohibiting clients from rescuing the possibility of filing criminal proceedings against counterparties in private civil actions.
(1) Criminal cases are related to client civil lawsuits
(2) The lawyer is convinced that both civil and criminal charges are legitimate by law and fact. (3) Attorneys do not attempt to demonstrate or suggest any inappropriate impact on criminal disposition.
Under such circumstances, the threat of criminal prosecution may be permitted, so the ABA Committee is permitted to enter into a customer contract with lawyers refraining from prostitution under similar circumstances.
On behalf of the Minnesota State Attorney's Office, the first vice president who wrote on behalf of expert responsibility in the 1998 article said, "Minnesota Bar Association has officially adopted ABA Opinion 92-363 , The Board of Directors will also be useful in analyzing complaints claiming the threat of criminal prosecution in civil litigation using opinions. " In this article, we analyzed several scenarios and discussed ethically recognized actions against "ABA analysis". However, this article did not state that the special responsibility of the Minnesota State Attorneys Office will reach the same conclusion.
One reason why the Minnesota office did not officially adopt the ABA opinion is that the ABA opinion that allows the threat of criminal prosecution, unlike Minnesota, is based on the model criminal law that defines the crime related to this type of behavior It is because it is. Model Criminal Law does not criminalize the threat of prosecution when an actor is seeking compensation.
The Minnesota state criminal law is not very clear.
A Minnesota lawyer representing a potential criminal lawyer must consider theft of theft with a witness before negotiating a confidentiality clause or "prosecution appeal" clause. A person commits a witness crime if that person uses "compulsion" in order to "refuse the witness to provide information to law enforcement agencies on crime".
If a lawyer can successfully overcome the Minnesota state criminal law in negotiating a settlement contract clause where lawyers refuse prosecution, he may find that the risk of criminal acts and ethical sanctions are not worth the effort.
First, attorneys should not recognize that certain crimes, such as crimes against certain financial institutions, are undergoing mandatory reporting measures that are required to report crime to law enforcement agencies It will not. Second, attorneys should consider what relief (if any) is possible if the victim has violated the contract and reported the action to the law enforcement agency after collecting the civil claim, There must be. Third, lawyers can never guarantee that criminal prosecution will not be materialized. Prosecutors can pursue criminal proceedings with or without the consent of the victims. The prosecutor can summon the victim to the procedure of the grand jury or testify at the criminal trial. At trial, victims who submitted false testimony are subject to false certification.
In short, attorneys who choose to negotiate the criminal aspects of civil lawsuits must be careful to stay within the relevant jurisdiction of the criminal law, there is no fail-safe way to avoid prosecution To the customer.
EmoticonEmoticon